Time For the DNR to Go?

August 17, 2015 at 8:12 pm 1 comment

By Andrew Richter

OK, my friends and enemies; I’m not feeling well so I’m going to be extra mean.

You all who know me know that I believe in small and limited government and no state has more unnecessary than Minnesota. Now, I’ve discussed my dislike of the unconstitutional Met Council, and as much as I can;t stand the Met Council, the Department of Natural resources or DNR is perhaps just as bad or worse.

Just ask the folks over at Mille Lacs Lake;

There was anger, sadness and a bit of resignation Sunday when the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources announced it was shutting down walleye fishing on Lake Mille Lacs midseason for the first time in history. The cutoff, aimed at protecting a record low walleye population, was 10 p.m. Monday. DNR Commissioner Tom Landwehr called it “a dark day for anglers in Minnesota.”

The brunt of anger from Mille Lacs resort owners was directed at Gov. Mark Dayton, state conservation officials and the eight Chippewa bands that have treaty rights dating back to 1837 to share fishing on the lake. “I feel like nobody listened,” said Linda Eno, owner of Twin Pines Resort in Garrison. “I was sitting with some customers when I got the text … they are sick about it, sick. Everybody is disgusted, saddened and sickened.

Ms. Eno maybe you should contribute to the Alliance for a Bitter Minnesota. That might get the governor’s attention.

I’ve already had cancellations, multiple cancellations. I’m hoping that people already booked will be OK with fishing bass and perch.

Ha! I’m sure they will go somewhere else! Never fear though, like all good government bureaucrats, the DNR commissioner “understands.”

“We all understand the gravity of this situation,” Landwehr said. “It’s traumatic for anglers and for those who rely on fishing.”

Wow, how riveting! I know I feel better!

John Odle, owner of Rocky Reef Resort in Onamia, said, “The commissioner needs to resign or quit or be fired … They need to go. The whole system has to be redone.”

Good luck with that!

Just three years ago, the quota for walleye on Mille Lacs was a half-million pounds. This year, it was 40,000 pounds. About two-thirds of that quota — or 28,600 pounds — was for sport fishermen; one-third was for the tribes. Anglers this year have been limited to one walleye per person. On Sunday, Landwehr and fisheries section chief Don Pereira said the sport fishermen’s allotment already has been exceeded by at least 2,000 pounds. Not included is 750 pounds of walleye that succumbed after a recent catch-and-release tournament and an unknown number that will die as hooking and releasing continues through Dec. 1.

Can I ask a question? How do you know what has pulled out and what hasn’t? I fished on Mille Lacs over the 4th of July and nobody weighed or even looked at what I caught (and I didn’t walk away empty-handed) so I’m wondering where these numbers come from.

Landwehr and Pereira repeatedly stressed Sunday that the smallmouth bass, northern pike and muskie fishing on the lake remains “outstanding.” 

Yeah then there will be a bass or northern “crisis.”

That failed to satisfy Greg Fisher, who owns Fisher’s Resort. “It’s a walleye lake — that’s the thing,” he said. “People just don’t want to switch. If we can get people to switch to bass or northern, that will be good, but I don’t know if they will.”

Just wait until you hear the Governor’s solution;

Dayton was in Isle for a town-hall meeting Friday, where he reiterated his plan for short-term financial help for area businesses hurt by the walleye season shutdown and a special legislative session if needed.

So the solution is to turn the Mille Lacs area into a welfare state.

He said big leadership changes are coming for the Aitkin office of the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) and he announced that the Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe would forgo its walleye harvest next year.

Big changes are coming! And those are……

Landwehr and Pereira said Sunday that the DNR plans to put a research and stocking station on the shores of the lake in the future, while adding research and management muscle — such as a full-time biologist — right away.

Add another government employee and do a study; those are some new ideas!

The biggest problem appears to be that something seems to be killing the young fish, officials said. Predation by larger fish, including walleyes, too-high water temperatures, zebra mussels, spiny water fleas and invasive plant species all were mentioned as possible contributors. “They’re not out of the woods until they’re 2½-year-old fish,” Pereira said.

Maybe you should solve that then!

Since the DNR began doing assessments in 1983, he’s “never seen walleyes this low,” Pereira said. Fishing by the bands is still a little under their quota, but their take of walleye is not the problem, Landwehr said. The Mille Lacs Band’s decision was “a good-faith effort,” he said, but is “not going to make a significant difference in the harvest or significant recovery of the lake.”

So the bands fishing for walleye are not the problem, but everyone else fishing for walleye is the problem. That sure makes a lot of sense.

As for short-term help for the businesses that rely on the lake to earn a living, Landwehr said Explore Minnesota, the Department of Employment and Economic Development and the Department of Revenue all are involved. Explore Minnesota already plans to spend $30,000 to tout the beautiful beaches and countryside and great fishing (besides walleye) in the area. Other help could include short-term loans or property-tax abatements, DNR officials said.

Good God!

The DNR is not keen on stocking the lake for walleye, but isn’t opposed to it, either, if the spawning population falls below a threshold. “Our messaging has been pretty clear,” Pereira said. “Walleyes are doing just fine producing new fish. If we can’t stem this declining trend in spawners, we’ll have to come in … and take eggs from Mille Lacs and collect those and put them back. It’s what we had to do in Red Lake in ’99 to bring those fish back.” It’s what we had to do in Red Lake in ’99 to bring those fish back.” It’s too soon to say what the outlook for 2016 is, Landwehr and Pereira said. The DNR will assess walleye numbers in August and September. If the numbers aren’t sufficient, 2016 could be a catch-and-release year, and the Chippewa bands then would do only ceremonial fishing, the officials said. Pereira said that, in the past, they have seen elevated mortality levels on Lake Kabetogama and in the western basin of Lake Vermilion, but those situations never reached the dire state of Mille Lacs.

Now, nothing said here makes any sense here. I fished on Lake Kabetogama last year and caught tons of walleye but I could hardly keep a thing thanks to the dumb DNR slot rules! The walleye population is clearly up yet they don’t change the rules. Also if there are no walleye in Mille Lacs then why not let people fish for them? They shouldn’t catch any if there are none there right? You ever fished a day in your life Mr. Pereira?

To me, the time has come to debate the usefulness of the DNR. They hold tremendous power that affects businesses, sportsman, travelers, and cabin owners and a debate about their power is long overdue. For now, I feel bad for the people on Mille Lacs who are being shut down by government pencil pushers.

DNR Article



Entry filed under: Agenda 21, City Government, Environment. Tags: , , .

Bowman and Libby Attack! New Hope Looking at a 7% Tax Increase

1 Comment Add your own

  • 1. Gene  |  August 17, 2015 at 8:29 pm

    This is a classic tragedy of the commons problem. Because no one owns the lake, no one has incentive to manage the long term health of the lake resources. Time to privatize waterway ownership.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

#mc_embed_signup{background:#fff; clear:left; font:14px Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif; } /* Add your own MailChimp form style overrides in your site stylesheet or in this style block. We recommend moving this block and the preceding CSS link to the HEAD of your HTML file. */

Twitter Updates

Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.


%d bloggers like this: